We performed a comparison between Melissa Data Quality and SAP Data Quality Management based on real PeerSpot user reviews.
Find out in this report how the two Data Quality solutions compare in terms of features, pricing, service and support, easy of deployment, and ROI."Provides quality accurate data that our downstream solutions depend on."
"SSIS integration."
"We are able to more accurately identify valid, and better formatted, data which improves the data we store in our database."
"We like having the ability to write our own utilities/software to process our records and store the final output the way we want."
"Decreases chances of incorrect shipping addresses and, thus, returned packages."
"Address verification ensures our customers get their packages, and we aren’t charged for incomplete address information."
"Address parsing. Our other software does not have this functionality."
"We only use the one feature for the NAICS code. This allows our product users to know what industry a business is in."
"We work with API standards or norms for internal applications, so it's essential for SSE to have tests and pass those tests according to the criteria, which makes SAP Data Quality Management very important for our products."
"Our primary use case is for us to inspect the results from the product and material, and for releasing or leaving the status of the product."
"It will mix up family members at times, so we will change addresses at times that shouldn’t be changed."
"There are some hitches in setup, especially with the new encoding, but otherwise it’s relatively simple."
"Needs more/better search tools are needed. Also, state and local tax data would be nice."
"To continually update the database with NAICS codes on businesses."
"One of the problems that we ran into this year was we probably spent over 40 hours finding and trying to drill down to where specific bugs were in the program, which was a tremendous waste of time for us. There were a couple of updates to Windows this year, the program kept crashing. It happened on two different occasions over a period of a few months. Once we told them what the problem was - even though their tech support is great to work with - it literally took probably about two months to fix the issue where we could actually use the program the way we needed to use it."
"Pricing is based on tiers, with each tier capped at a specified number of records processed. Once you go over the cap at one tier, you are automatically bumped to the next tier. However, they seem to count failed batch processes so it’s good to keep track of the number of records sent. They’ll fix the count when notified, but their system fails to detect actual successful processes versus failed processes."
"It could always be cheaper."
"More countries should be supported by Melissa."
"SAP Data Quality Management would be better if it directly integrates with the ME system. Right now, the company has a lot of machines on the shop floor working as a standalone, so you have to use all methods to ensure that the data interface appears on the ME system and that SAP Data Quality Management records the QM results. It would be much easier if the ME system could be integrated directly with SAP Data Quality Management."
"I would like for them to develop a feature to able to record all of our inspections; so all the data can go through SAP. It's not user-friendly or easy to get further analysis, so we mostly skip this step."
Earn 20 points
Melissa Data Quality is ranked 9th in Data Quality with 40 reviews while SAP Data Quality Management is ranked 5th in Data Quality with 2 reviews. Melissa Data Quality is rated 8.4, while SAP Data Quality Management is rated 8.6. The top reviewer of Melissa Data Quality writes "SSIS MatchUp Component is Amazing". On the other hand, the top reviewer of SAP Data Quality Management writes "Scalable, stable, and offers good technical support". Melissa Data Quality is most compared with Informatica Address Verification, Precisely Trillium and Experian Data Quality, whereas SAP Data Quality Management is most compared with SAP Data Services, SAP Information Steward, Informatica Address Verification, Informatica Data Quality and Syniti Data Quality. See our Melissa Data Quality vs. SAP Data Quality Management report.
See our list of best Data Quality vendors.
We monitor all Data Quality reviews to prevent fraudulent reviews and keep review quality high. We do not post reviews by company employees or direct competitors. We validate each review for authenticity via cross-reference with LinkedIn, and personal follow-up with the reviewer when necessary.